AT&T Stock Drops on Justice Department’s Appeal of Time Warner Merger Ruling

AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner.

The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has opted to challenge a federal judge’s decision in its antitrust lawsuit seeking to block the transaction.

On Thursday, AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson told Variety he was not surprised by the government’s move and that he wasn’t worried that the DOJ action would derail the Time Warner pact, which closed last month.

“We’ve been to the court once and we got an order based on the law,” Stephenson said at the the Allen & Co. conference in Sun Valley, Idaho. “The judge did a very fact-based, thoughtful and thorough order. It’ll be evaluated on those grounds.”

On June 12, U.S. District Judge Richard Leon ruled in favor of AT&T-Time Warner, in a definitive opinion that rejected all of the government’s arguments. The judge also strongly suggested that the Justice Department not to seek a stay to block the merger as it pursued an appeal.

The DOJ’s odds of winning on appeal are low — but “they are not zero,” MoffettNathanson principal analyst Craig Moffett wrote in a research note. The Justice Department’s lawyers will likely focus on Leon’s flat-out rejection of the premise that a programmer (in this case, Turner) that is owned by a distributor (AT&T) would negotiate any differently with other TV services.

There is “at least a reasonable basis for the appeal,” Moffett wrote.

In any case, one of the big winners from the latest development is Disney, according to Moffett. That’s because the DOJ’s challenge to AT&T-Time Warner will give 21st Century Fox’s board justification to reject Comcast’s bid for major Fox assets — and choose Disney (as a horizontal merger) over Comcast (a vertical merger) as the path of lower regulatory risk.

“Whether [the DOJ’s appeal] puts a damper on all vertical M&A remains to be seen,” Moffett wrote. “But this is certainly not the ‘anything goes’ M&A regime that many thought we had, shortly after the 2016 election.”

— Cynthia Littleton contributed to this report.

More Politics

  • Sinclair

    FCC Says Sinclair May Have Misrepresented Tribune Merger Details

    AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner. The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has […]

  • Video Games Offer Unique Way Forward

    Video Games Offer Unique Way Forward for Journalists

    AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner. The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has […]

  • Sinclair

    FCC Votes to Send Sinclair-Tribune Merger to Administrative Hearing

    AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner. The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has […]

  • At&t Time Warner Stock Index

    Justice Department Gives Glimpse of Appeal Argument in AT&T-Time Warner Case

    AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner. The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has […]

  • US Capitol

    House Rejects Proposal to Cut NEA Funding by 15%

    AT&T shares fell as much as 2% in early trading Friday, after the U.S. Department of Justice filed to appeal a decision that gave the OK for the telco’s acquisition of Time Warner. The decline reflects investor concern that AT&T’s takeover of Time Warner is not necessarily a done deal, as the Justice Department has […]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content